Tuesday, November 11, 2014

From 2009 to 2013, Brazil’s Police Killed Six per Day

Though it’s an issue that has been widely reported on of late, the level of police violence in Brazil is shocking nonetheless. From 2009 to 2013 police in the country killed at least 11,197 people, an average of six people per day over five years.

The staggering figure comes from the latest annual report by the Brazilian Public Security Forum (FBSP). While the full FBSP publication is set to be released later today, it has already made this morning’s headlines in the Brazilian press.  

The total of those killed at the hands of police authorities last year was 2,212, a slight drop from 2,332 the year before but slightly more than the 2,177 seen in 2009. As Folha reports, Rio de Janeiro was the state with the most police killings in 2013, even though the number fell to 416 from 1,048 in 2009. FBSP Director Samira Bueno described this drop to the paper as an indicator of the success of Rio’s Police Pacification Units (UPPs), “the only good news” in a wave of bad news.

In São Paulo, the figure dropped from 566 to 364, but recent numbers are less hopeful. The state’s Public Safety Department just released statistics showing that Paulista police killed more people between January and September than they did during the same period for the past 10 years, including twice as many as the same period in 2013.

O Globo provides a comparative look at the Forum figures, noting that Brazilian police killed more victims in the five-year period than United States police have in the last 30 years (11,090), despite the U.S. having a population roughly 50 percent larger.

Another striking feature of the report is the FBSP’s estimates regarding the economic impact of violent crime in the country. As Agencia Brasil and Veja report, last year violence cost the country approximately $100 billion, approximately 5.4 percent of its GDP.

The Forum report fits well with the recent death squad-style killings in the northeastern city of Belem, allegedly committed by groups of off-duty policemen seeking revenge for the murder of a colleague.

Also relevant is a recently-broadcast NPR report on violence in the country by South America Correspondent Lulu Garcia-Navarro, who reminds Brazil-watchers that not all of the country’s citizens experience insecurity in the same way. The piece notes that over the past decade, homicides among white Brazilians have fallen 24 percent, while among the country’s black population they have increased by 40 percent.

For Robert Muggah of the Rio-based Igarape Institute, the difference has to do with economic inequality. As Muggah remarked to NPR: “Those who are white tend to be able to afford themselves and avail themselves of greater security, and we are seeing reductions in homicides[…]Those who are black and who are unable to — as our societies become more and more unequal — are less able to secure those public goods, and as a result are seeing homicide rates going up.”

News Briefs
  • Also on Brazil, O Globo reports on a new study on the application of Brazil’s much-lauded freedom of information law commissioned by the Fundação Getúlio Vargas. According to FGV researchers, 69 percent of freedom of information requests submitted to various state and federal institutions were answered, while 57 percent of responses were fully granted. The study found wide variation across states, however, with Rio officials answering 38 percent and fully granting just 18 percent of requests.
  • Mexican President Enrique Peña Nieto may be in China for trade talks, but protests against his handling of the investigation into the 43 missing students in Guerrero, as well as over allegations of corruption, have continued in his absence. Animal Politico reports that protests led by students and relatives of the missing victims in Acapulco succeeded in shutting down the city’s airport for three hours. Meanwhile, the president has come under increasing pressure to explain this weekend’s  Aristegui Noticias report revealing that a $7 million mansion owned by the Peña Nieto family was built and is registered under the name of a company that recently won a controversial bid to build a controversial high-speed rail system. While the president canceled the contract in response to allegations of backroom deals, the Wall Street Journal reports that a Chinese partner of the company is threatening to pursue legal action against the president for the cancelation. The Guardian notes that the Peña Nieto administration has issued a statement claiming that the house belongs to his wife, First Lady Angelica Rivera, who has been paying it off in installments since January 2012.
  • In today’s New York Times, Enrique Krauze has an op-ed comparing the likely killing of the 43 Guerrero students with a 1967 massacre of peasants in the city of Atoyac, near Acapulco, an incident which  “unleashed the Mexican Left,” in his words. For Krauze, the student massacre bears traces of this same political violence, as well as the work of drug cartels looking to crush revolutionary elements that are “bad for business.”
  • A week after being diagnosed with what doctors called an “infectious fever” and colitis, Argentine President Cristina Fernandez was released from the hospital on Sunday. However, according to La Nacion, her medical team has ordered her to rest for the next ten days. The AP reports that Argentines are largely unfazed by her latest ailment, a likely result of her frequent health issues.
  • In a Razon Publica column, Dejusticia researcher Nelson Camilo Sanchez attempts to paint a more nuanced picture of Colombia’s conflict victims than the one depicted in local and international press, noting victims’ groups wide variety in demands and backgrounds as well as the complexities associated with implementing reparations under the country’s new Victims’ Law.
  • El Espectador reports that today is a “historic day” for Colombia, as senators in the country are set to begin debate over a proposal to legalize cannabis for medical purposes, an initiative which has the clear support of President Juan Manuel Santos.
  • UNASUR Secretary General Ernesto Samper appears to be trying to restart failed talks between the Venezuelan government and the opposition. As El Universal reports, Samper took advantage of a meeting with Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff on Monday to call for a “grand social pact” to guarantee the integrity of elections and government institutions, as well as “a series of measures to adjust the economy, which are needed.”
  • The government of Haiti has indicated dissatisfaction with a Dominican Constitutional Tribunal ruling which effectively withdraws the country’s recognition of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights. Proceso also reports that Haitian Foreign Minister Duly Brutus told reporters the individuals who are affected by the Dominican Republic’s recent citizenship policies are in fact Dominican, perfectly illustrating how this population is at risk of becoming essentially stateless. Meanwhile the Open Society Justice Initiative has a good explanation for why the Constitutional Tribunal’s IACHR ruling is invalid, noting that the country’s recognition of the regional court was conducted in accordance with the constitution at the time, and that the Tribunal itself has consistently recognized the jurisdiction of the Inter-American Court.
  • Authorities in Trinidad and Tobago are preparing to launch a massive immigration crackdown, giving the country’s estimated 110,000 undocumented immigrants until January to resolve their legal status or face deportation in “door-to-door” raids, according to local paper Newsday. But while authorities in the Caribbean nation say a wave of undocumented immigration is fueling an increase in crime, InSight Crime points out the flaws in this argument.

Monday, November 10, 2014

Official: Mexico's 43 Missing Students Killed

Mexican Attorney General Jesus Murillo Karam has told reporters that officials have reason to believe the 43 missing students in Guerrero have been killed, their bodies then burned in a garbage dump. But while the case appears to be nearing its conclusion, mass outrage over the disappearances continues.

In a press conference on Friday, Murillo Karam said that three suspects in custody had told investigators that police turned over the students to members of the Guerreros Unidos drug gang, who piled them into trucks and drove them to a dump outside Iguala to be massacred. In video shown to reporters -- see CNN Mexico -- suspects said some of the 43 had died of asphyxiation along the way.

Despite the revelations, Proceso points out that Murillo Karam cautioned reporters that because the remains have not yet been identified, the case is still open. As the New York Times notes, the attorney general said that with 72 suspects arrested, the police effort amounts to one of the largest criminal investigations in the country’s history.

Even so, the announcement has left the victims’ families, human rights groups and the general public unsatisfied. On Saturday, a peaceful demonstration in Mexico City’s zocalo ended with a group of protesters attempting to set fire to and break down the door to the National Palace. The Associated Press notes that Murillo Karam’s dismissal of reporters following an hour-long press conference -- in which he said “Ya me cansé “(“Enough, I’m tired”) -- fueled an immediate backlash on social media,  with users playing off of the phrase to signal their own dissatisfaction with the country’s corruption and criminal violence.

Animal Politico reports that representatives of the families held a press conference of their own following Murillo Karam’s remarks, in which they said they would not put faith in the government investigation unless it was confirmed by the independent researchers of the Argentine Forensic Anthropology Team (EAAF).

In spite of the overwhelming public outrage and repeated calls from civil society to cancel his plans, President Enrique Peña Nieto set out yesterday on a weeklong trip to China and Australia to attend the APEC and G20 forums.  The AFP reports that the decision came under fire from local and international human rights groups, with Amnesty International claiming that it showed Peña Nieto’s “lack of interest in confronting the grave human rights situation in Mexico.”

According to El Economista, the Mexican leader has responded to critics by saying that it would have been “easier and more comfortable” to stay in the country and skip the summits, he chose not to because of the impact “on the economy of our country and job creation.”

News Briefs
  • The case of the missing 43 students is not the only scandal Peña Nieto is facing at the moment. According to a bombshell investigation published on Aristegui Noticias, the website of journalist Carmen Aristegui, the president’s $7 million mansion was built and is registered under the name of a company that recently won a controversial bid to build a controversial high-speed rail system. As the Wall Street Journal reports, the contract was canceled and the bidding was restarted last week amid claims that the process was the result of backroom deals, charges that the Aristegui article seem to confirm.
  • The Miami Herald takes a look at the indigenous justice system in Colombia, where seven alleged FARC members accused of killing two local community guard members in Cauca have received strict sentences for their crimes, including public lashings and 40 to 60-year jail sentences.
  • InSight Crime profiles the Honduran government’s plan to build two new prison complexes and pardon low-level offenders, part of an initiative meant to reduce overcrowding in the country’s penal system. However, as the author points out, the move is no substitute for UN-approved best practices for reducing prison populations, like implementing revised sentencing guidelines and decreasing the use of pre-trial detention.
  • O Globo reports that police in the northern Brazilian city of Belem have begun receiving testimony regarding last week’s murder of ten people by alleged off-duty police officers in retaliation for the murder of a military policeman. So far, however, no suspects are in custody.
  • The New York Times reports on a Brazilian military drill starting today in the Amazon, which is intended to simulate an external invasion of the rainforest and reflects concerns that foreign interests covet the country’s natural resources.
  • The AP reports that Argentine narcotics experts claim that the amount of drugs passing through the Southern Cone country is increasing, due in part to rising drug consumption as well as its status as a maritime bridge to the European market.

Friday, November 7, 2014

Venezuela Official’s Brazil Visit Raises Eyebrows

Former Venezuelan Foreign Minister Elias Jaua’s peculiar visit to Brazil has made headlines, and for good reason. The story touches on elements of nearly every major ailment facing Venezuela today: deteriorating regional relations, corruption, flagging health services and special treatment for the well-connected.

The trouble began for Jaua in late October, when -- as O Estado de S. Paulo first reported -- he accompanied his wife to Brazil, where she had scheduled medical exams. Upon her arrival, doctors apparently told her that she needed immediate surgery, and Jaua sent for his children and the family nanny. But when the latter arrived, she was detained by authorities for carrying a pistol in her luggage, a fact which Jaua explained by saying that she was not aware he had left the handgun in his briefcase.

This controversy was barely resolved when, on Wednesday, Brazil’s Foreign Ministry issued a protest to Jaua’s meeting with the Landless Workers Movement (MST), in which he apparently signed a formal agreement. The AP characterizes the move as “a rare rebuke from a staunch ally” in the region.

The incident is impressive for how many of the major criticisms leveled against the Chavista government it manages to encompass at once. Never mind the fact that Jaua travelled on a government plane for a seemingly personal trip. Or the irony in the fact that his wife had to travel to Brazil to seek adequate health care when Venezuela’s hospitals lack key medical equipment. Or the suspicious fact that his nanny carried a handgun into the country for him. Why is the ex-foreign minister of Venezuela, who was demoted recently to the vaguely broad title of “Minister of Communes and Social Movements and Vice President for the Development of Domestic Socialism,” signing agreements with non-state actors in Brazil without proper authorization? 

News Briefs
  • On Wednesday, Reuters broke the news that Venezuelan paper Ultimas Noticias was purchased by British media mogul Robert Hanson despite its sizeable debt and falling profit margin. This, as well as recent examples of self-censorship at the paper, has led to speculation that the change in ownership is part of a government strategy to restrict unfavorable media coverage.
  • Today’s Wall Street Journal features an analysis of the investigations into the alleged death squad killings in the northern Brazilian city of Belen, which came after the death of a military police officer on Tuesday. As noted in yesterday’s briefing, the total death toll has risen to ten, and local press have gathered statements from dozens of locals who report seeing masked gunmen on motorcycles -- allegedly off-duty military police -- carrying out the killings.
  • The Constitutional Court of the Dominican Republic’s recent decision to annul the country’s acceptance of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights has been met with strong condemnation from international human rights groups. Yesterday, Amnesty International’s Americas Director Erika Guevara Rosas criticized the decision as a confirmation of the local court’s “lack of independence and impartiality, proving it to be politically biased by defending narrow interests.”  The remark was reported in leading Dominican daily El Listin Diario, which published today’s edition under a headline noting the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights has questioned the validity of the Constitutional Court decision under international law.
  • InSight Crime has an in-depth analysis of the implications of the recent marijuana policy votes in Alaska, Washington DC and Oregon in Latin America, as well as an excellent summary of the drug laws of countries across the hemisphere.
  • Animal Politico reports that Mexico’s Defense Ministry (SEDENA) has announced that it will follow the recommendations of the country’s National Human Rights Commission (CNDH) in the wake of the June 30 Tlatlaya massacre. In its investigation, the CNDH established that soldiers killed at least 12 and probably 15 of 22 suspects in custody, and rearranged their bodies after the incident in order to make the deaths fit the official story of a fierce firefight. The CNDH recommendations included a call to recommend all those linked to the killings, as well as to look into the possibility that a high-ranking officer may have shared responsibility for the incident.
  • Police in Colombia’s Cauca province say that members of the FARC killed two members of a local indigenous community as punishment for removing a billboard commemorating the death of late rebel leader Alfonso Cano. In response, UN authorities in the country have expressed alarm and called on the FARC to respect the autonomy and human rights of indigenous groups in the country. According to El Espectador and Semana, the community has rounded up seven suspected guerrillas they say is responsible for the killings, who will be prosecuted in accordance with the local justice system.
  • The first wave of runoff polling between presidential candidates Tabare Vazquez and Luis Alberto Lacalle Pou has begun in Uruguay following the first-round and legislative vote on October 26. An Equipos Mori poll released yesterday shows Vazquez with huge lead over Lacalle Pou, with 53 to 38 percent.
  • The story of Uruguayan President Jose Mujica’s million-dollar offer to sell his signature VW bug has been widely picked up in international press.  Mujica, for his part, has said he is willing to sell the automobile and use the proceeds to benefit social programs in his country, as he has “no commitment” to cars. “But if they ask me for Manuela, it would be different,” Mujica told reporters, referring to the name of his three-legged dog that has become part of his wildly popular homespun image. As an indication of how successfully Mujica’s lifestyle has resonated among Uruguayans, Manuela herself was the subject of a 950-word profile hosted on the site of popular daily El Observador earlier this week.
  • For the first time since Ecuador’s top court ruled that his Alianza Pais party could reform the constitution allowing for indefinite re-election instead of a popular vote, President Rafael Correa has broached the subject of running for office again in 2017. As AFP reports, Correa has said that the decision will ultimately lie with his party, and that it will most likely be decided in “October or November of 2016.” Meanwhile, opposition figure Guillermo Lasso has applied with electoral officials to begin gathering signatures to force a referendum on the re-election issue, according to El Comercio.

Thursday, November 6, 2014

Rubio: GOP Senate Sweep Could Push Venezuela Sanctions

United States Senator Marco Rubio (R-FL) has offered one of the first predictions of how Sunday’s midterm elections could impact U.S. foreign policy in Latin America. The senator, who is in Colombia for a two-day visit to discuss trade and security issues, gave a press conference in Bogota yesterday in which he broached the subject of neighboring Venezuela.

While Rubio welcomed the Obama administration’s July decision to institute a ban on U.S. travel for Venezuelan officials linked to rights abuses, he told reporters he hoped the new Republican majority in the Senate could “achieve something much stronger than what the White House has done so far.” From the AP’s Josh Goodman:
Rubio said the sanctions bill would have already been approved if not for the objections of his Democrat colleague, Sen. Mary Landrieu of Louisiana, who has stalled a vote out of worries over hundreds of jobs at a refinery owned by Citgo, a subsidiary of Venezuela's state-run oil company. Landrieu faces a December runoff ballot with a Republican challenger after failing to secure a majority of votes in Tuesday's election.
Despite the arguments against sanctions put forward by Venezuelan human rights groups and political analysts like Luis Vicente Leon, it appears many on Capitol Hill assumed the bipartisan sanctions measure would easily pass. But as Politico reported in August, Landrieu and Citgo worked together to block the bill at the last minute, with the company claiming it had concerns that the official interpretation of the bill could change over time and leave it vulnerable to restrictions as well.

Interestingly, while Rubio has criticized Colombia’s peace talks with FARC rebels in the past -- the Miami Herald notes he is “among the U.S. lawmakers who have voiced concerns that the peace deal may be too lenient” -- he has so far been decidedly diplomatic in his remarks on the peace process. As EFE reports, the senator responded to a question on post-conflict aid by saying that he supports shifting anti-drug assistance from Plan Colombia to economic aid, “to turn the progress achieved so far into something permanent.”

News Briefs
  • Yesterday marked a day of international protests  in solidarity with the disappearance of the 43 Mexican students of Ayotzinapa, and it seems the arrest of Iguala Mayor Jose Luis Abarca has failed to satisfy popular outrage over the incident. Mexico City saw hundreds of thousands turn out for demonstrations yesterday, and Animal Politico reports that parallel protests took place around the country and in major cities in Chile, Bolivia, Brazil, Spain, France, Switzerland and Germany, to name a few.
  • While the rallying cry for these protests has been “vivos los queremos,” El Universal  reports that the parents of the missing 43 say that in their interaction with officials, they have been repeatedly told that their children are likely dead. However, several said they will refuse to believe the government’s claim until it is confirmed by the Argentine Forensic Anthropology Team (EAAF) that is assisting the official investigation.  
  • Colombia’s El Tiempo reports that police in Cartagena have arrested the suspect accused of ordering the murder of Venezuelan Congressman Robert Serra last month. In the weeks following the killing, Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro said a “Colombian paramilitary” was behind the crime, but the motive remains unclear.
  • Argentine President Cristina Fernandez’s medical team has announced that the leader is “in a stable condition” while being treated for a bacterial infection of the colon. Her doctors have also said that she has been ordered to rest “a minimum of 10 days” after leaving the hospital, though they have not provided a date for her release, as the Wall Street Journal reports.
  • Uruguayan Foreign Minister Luis Almagro is stepping up his campaign to be the next OAS Secretary General, traveling to the Caribbean this week to visit Cuba and then drum up support for his candidacy from the governments of Jamaica, Grenada and the Bahamas, according to El Pais.
  • Following the murder of ten people around the northern Brazilian city of Belem on Tuesday night -- which came amid reports from local residents that the killings were retaliation for the murder of a police officer -- Para state officials say they will investigate the shootings. O Globo claims that authorities believe the crime was in fact committed by a “death squad” seeking vengeance, and quotes witnesses saying that the killings were carried out by masked gunmen on motorbikes seeking to “cleanse” targeted areas.
  • In his latest Miami Herald op-ed, syndicated columnist Andres Oppenheimer argues that the passage of marijuana legalization initiatives in Washington DC, Oregon and Alaska are the start of a potential credibility crisis for U.S. anti-drug efforts abroad, especially in Latin America.
  • In the New Yorker, Jon Lee Anderson has an analysis of Cuba’s unparalleled efforts to fight the Ebola epidemic in West Africa, arguing that the country is uniquely poised to commit doctors to the fight to contain the outbreak. As Anderson writes: “health-workers are an exportable resource that, with an investment in schools, a small country without many natural ones can produce on a large scale. Castro’s medical internationalism has been a huge financial boon to the island, earning it an estimated eight billion dollars a year.”
  • In a Huffington Post column, anti-corruption advocate Frank Vogl argues that the Obama administration has a unique opportunity to call for a new international treaty to protect civil society organizations when he attends upcoming summits in China and Australia. Among the examples of vulnerable transparency NGOs cited by Vogl is Honduras’ Asociación para una Sociedad Mas Justa, which he includes among groups facing “harassment and intimidation by their national authorities.”

Wednesday, November 5, 2014

Dominican Republic Overturns Recognition of Inter-American Court

In a ruling that suspiciously coincides with the Inter-American Court of Human Rights’ condemnation of the country’s immigration practices, the Dominican Constitutional Court has ruled that the country’s 1999 recognition of the regional human rights court’s jurisdiction was not properly ratified by lawmakers. Effectively, the decision amounts to the Dominican Republic’s immediate withdrawal of the jurisdiction of the Inter-American Court, as El Listin Diario and Acento report.

In a 59-page decision posted online yesterday evening, which was supported by 10 of 13 judges, the Dominican court ruled in favor of a 2005 challenge to the regional human rights court’s mandate. One of the primary pieces of evidence used by the court was a certification that “in the Senate archives there is no resolution ratifying the jurisdiction of the IACHR.”

The Inter-American Court of Human Rights’ recent ruling ordering the D.R. to invalidate last year’s citizenship ruling that left thousands of people stateless put Dominican authorities in a tight spot.  On top of the country’s human rights obligations under the American Convention, the Dominican Constitution establishes that in the event of a contradiction between a national court ruling and an international one, the ruling that is most favorable to individual rights-holders takes precedence. So from the Dominican government’s perspective, yesterday’s Constitutional Court decision makes things much simpler. The ruling gives authorities a green light to continue their discriminatory policies towards Haitian immigrants and Dominicans of Haitian descent without worrying about their legal consequences.

According to the OAS database the Inter-American Court has issued no fewer than four judgments (and one clarifying interpretation) regarding the Dominican Republic since 1999.  Yesterday’s ruling essentially strips these of their legal weight, though -- as the Associated Press notes -- the D.R. has failed to fully comply with them anyway.

The AP also reports that the decision will make the Dominican Republic the third country in the hemisphere to withdraw from the regional court’s jurisdiction (after Venezuela and Trinidad and Tobago), but in fact the Dominican case is more nuanced. By finding that the human rights court’s jurisdiction was never properly ratified, the Dominican Republic is not technically denouncing the American Convention, and will not have to wait a full year for its withdrawal to take effect as Venezuela recently did.

It will be interesting to see how the United States government reacts -- if it reacts at all -- to the decision.  While the Obama administration has pushed Dominican officials to resolve the contradictions stemming from last year’s citizenship ruling, the fact that the U.S. has not ratified the American Convention (let alone the Inter-American Court’s jurisdiction) means it is not in a place to criticize the Dominican Republic.

News Briefs
  • Following yesterday’s announcement that fugitive Iguala Mayor Jose Luis Abarca and his wife, Maria de los Angeles Pineda, had been arrested in Mexico City, the Attorney General’s Office has released more details on the operation that led to their capture. As El Universal and the AP detail, investigators were keeping an eye on various properties owned by the couple and were tipped off when a female accomplice kept making visits to an apparently empty house.
  • The murder of a Brazilian military police officer in Belem yesterday was followed by a string of shootings in the northern city, killing at least nine. The incident appears to be the latest illustration of an apparent lack of police oversight in Brazil, as Globo and Veja report that local residents in neighborhoods around the city took to social media last night to claim that police were launching a retaliatory “massacre” in response to the death of their own.
  • In the latest editorial in support of improved relations with Cuba, Sunday’s New York Times featured a call for the Obama administration to swap three Cuban spies held in the U.S. for imprisoned USAID contractor Alan Gross.
  • Bolivian ombudsman (Defensor del Pueblo) Rolando Villena has issued an official statement expressing concern over the levels of sexual violence against women and girls in the country following a series of high-profile attacks, the BBC reports.
  • President Juan Manuel Santos is in Europe this week, on a marathon tour of EU countries with the stated aim of securing economic support for a post-conflict development initiative that he has described as “a kind of Marshall Plan.” But in an analysis of his schedule by La Silla Vacia, the news site suggests that the tour is more about obtaining political support for ongoing peace talks with FARC rebels. Coinciding with the tour, the Financial Times has published an editorial laying out three reasons to support the FARC talks, pointing to their ability to improve regional cohesion, security and economic growth.
  • Spanish news agency EFE reports on a Monday meeting of representatives from all branches of the Paraguayan government in Asuncion, in which authorities resolved to crack down on the influence of drug trafficking and criminal networks. Among the measures passed is a resolution to try all drug trafficking-related cases in Asuncion courts rather than in more vulnerable courts in the country’s periphery.
  • The Miami Herald reports on a new immigration practice that recently took effect in the Bahamas, which migrant rights advocates say has led to the detention of dozens children, mostly of mostly Haitian origin.

Tuesday, November 4, 2014

A New ‘Pact for Mexico’ on Security

While the much-lauded grand bargain between Mexico’s three main political parties (the PRI, PAN and PRD) known as the “Pact for Mexico” broke down over energy reform, public outrage at Mexico’s security crisis may giving it new life.

Today’s El Universal and Milenio report that President Enrique Peña Nieto has announced that, independently of the Attorney General Office’s investigation into the disappearance of 43 students in Guerrero, he plans to push institutional reforms to ensure that such incidents do not repeat themselves.  “In the coming days, I will call for representatives of the Mexican government, political forces and civil society organizations to make a commitment to undertake fundamental change, strengthen our institutions and, above all, to ensure the full effectiveness of the rule of law in the country,” Peña Nieto said in a speech at the Palacio Nacional yesterday.

The president made the announcement while unveiling the secondary legislation to the country’s energy reform measure. As El Pais notes, this fact immediately led analysts to draw comparisons to the Pact for Mexico, which fell apart late last year due to the PRD’s opposition to reforming the country’s longstanding government monopoly in the oil and gas industry.

While the scope and durability of a new pact remains to be seen, the PRD, PAN and PRI have all released statements with similar expressions of support for reforms to reinforce the rule of law nationwide. Excelsior has a roundup of remarks from congressional leaders from all three parties on the proposal, which generally agree on the importance of ending impunity, prosecuting corruption and reducing violence.

News Briefs
  • Mexican officials say they have arrested Iguala Mayor Jose Luis Abarca and his wife, accused of ordering a harsh police crackdown on student protests in the city in September, which led to the kidnapping and disappearance of 43. Milenio reports that the two were found hiding out in the eastern Mexico City neighborhood of Iztapalapa.
  • Yesterday, the Peña Nieto administration announced the creation of a new civil society commission meant to oversee the investigation into the disappearance of the missing 43 students. EFE reports that authorities say it is made up of eight parents of the victims, four fellow students and five representatives of civil society organizations. But while the commission was launched as a result of the agreement signed by the president in a meeting with the Iguala relatives, Animal Politico claims that relatives of the victims held a press conference yesterday in Guerrero to reject the commission due to the lack of progress in the search.
  • Over at Venezuelan Politics and Human Rights, Rebecca Hanson profiles a potential obstacle to President Nicolas Maduro’s recently announced police reform proposal: the common perception among police in the country that the Maduro government does not support them. According to Hanson, the recent shakeup in response to the killing of five "colectivo" members by police in Caracas will only fuel this attitude and potentially encourage more extrajudicial executions.
  • For the New Yorker, Caracas-based reporter Girish Gupta looks at how the decline in world oil prices -- which have hit their lowest levels in four years -- could exacerbate Venezuela’s mounting economic problems. Ultimas Noticias reports that last night, Maduro announced a 15 percent increase in the minimum wage in order to keep up with inflation.
  • In a bid to increase foreign investment on the island, the Cuban government has released a “menu” of some 240 projects that they hope to be funded by foreign capital, totaling $8.7 billion, according to the Associated Press.
  • Writing for The American Interest, Russell Crandall takes the Obama administration to task for adopting a more flexible approach to drug policy at home while simultaneously supporting the tired old approach to the War on Drugs in Latin America. Part of this, Crandall argues, can be explained by the existence of what he calls an “impregnable military-narcotics-industrial complex, especially on the international side of the drug war,” which makes international anti-drug policy particularly hard to change in Washington.
  • Uruguay’s historic cannabis regulation law took another step forward on October 30, with the Institute for Regulation and Control of Cannabis (IRCCA) announcing that it will begin registering the first “marijuana membership clubs,” which under the law can have a maximum of 45 members and grow up to 99 plants (480 grams per user per year). In order to obtain a license, the clubs must meet a series of security requirements and first register as civil associations with the Ministry of Culture, which at least four have already done.
  • Politico Magazine has an in-depth look at the lack of oversight of the U.S. Border Patrol and the history of abuse among its ranks, painting a picture of “The Green Monster” as a police force run amok. According to Politico: “The United States today spends more money each year on border and immigration enforcement than the combined budgets of the FBI, ATF, DEA, Secret Service and U.S. Marshals—plus the entire NYPD annual budget. Altogether, the country has invested more than $100 billion in border and immigration control since 9/11…[T]he Border Patrol has also become one of the nation’s deadliest law enforcement agencies over that same period, involved in more fatal shootings—at least 46—since 2004 than perhaps any other such agency."
  • According to La Nacion, officials in Argentina have announced that President Cristina Fernandez will remain hospitalized for the next “three or four days,” where she is being treated with antibiotics due to an inflammation of the sigmoid colon.

Monday, November 3, 2014

Ecuador’s Top Court Backs Constitutional Reforms

Ecuadorean President Rafael Correa’s Alianza Pais political movement scored an important victory late last week. On Friday, the country’s Constitutional Court ruled that 16 of the party’s 17 proposals to reform the constitution can be passed via legislative vote rather than a popular referendum.  

According to La Hora, the only measure that the court claimed required a popular vote to change was a proposal to limit the ability of individuals to claim that their personal constitutional rights are being violated by invoking the writ of “amparo” in court. President Correa has in the past railed against what he claims is the rampant abuse of this measure by individuals seeking to get out of prosecution.

As El Universo reports, the 16 court-approved reforms include a number of minor tweaks to the 2008 constitution like lowering required minimum presidential age from 35 to 30, and giving municipal governments a greater role in education and health infrastructure. But the biggest and most controversial provisions include expanding the role of the military in domestic security, scrapping term limits for all elected officials, and recognizing communications as a “public service.”   Some international outlets -- see the Wall Street Journal -- have characterized the latter point as an expansion of the government's media oversight, but it is more accurately an attempt to solidify the aims of the country’s controversial 2013 media law, which contains similar language.

Ecuadorean lawyer Ricardo Flores, who has written an extensive three-part critique (see parts I, II and III) of the juridical arguments behind the reforms for news site Gkillcity.com, offers yet another critical take on the political ramifications of Friday’s decision. In Flores’ estimation, the Constitutional Court ruling is hardly surprising given that its judges are mostly aligned with Correa’s political movement. As he and El Universo point out, the ruling allows the Alianza Pais to allow indefinite reelection just in time for the 2017 general election.

Allegations of an assault on judicial independence against a leftist leader in Latin America are nothing new, of course, but in this case there is ample evidence to support them. As an excellent report published in August by the Due Process of Law Foundation, Colombia’s Dejusticia, and the Legal Defense Institute of Peru demonstrated, the Correa administration has exerted undue influence over courts since 2011 by sacking judges who do not conform to its political preferences.

Because the president’s Alianza Pais controls 100 of 137 seats in the National Assembly, the reforms are almost sure to pass a congressional vote. Thus, the opposition’s only hope of challenging the constitutional changes lies in presenting electoral officials with a petition with roughly 600,000 signatures in support of a referendum. On Saturday, opposition figure (and 2013 presidential candidate) Guillermo Lasso said he would support such a signature drive.

If Lasso follows through on his promise, he may have better luck than the failed Yasunidos environmental movement, which saw more than half of its gathered signatures invalidated by the National Electoral Council in May. Fortunately for the opposition, it appears to have public opinion largely on its side. According to a Cedatos poll released last month, 73 percent of the country is in favor of voting on a proposal to allow indefinite reelection.

News Briefs
  • On Sunday, Mexico’s Federal Judiciary Council issued a statement detailing the charges brought against those responsible for the June 30 execution of 22 individuals in Tlatlaya by members of the army.  A total of seven soldiers have been arrested and charged with “actions improper to the public service,” while three of these have been accused of killing eight of the victims, Animal Politico and the AP report.
  • The New York Times has a profile of the teachers’ college in Ayotzinapa attended by the 43 students who went missing in Iguala in September, noting its proud history of radical activism.
  • International media -- see Forbes and the AP -- have picked up on a protest in São Paulo on Sunday in which some 2,500 protesters came together to call for the impeachment of Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff in the wake of allegations against the president stemming from the deepening Petrobras scandal.  Local press like O Estado and Folha also highlighted remarks by a minority of protesters who called for a military coup to overthrow the president.
  • Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro is seemingly considering revising his predecessor Hugo Chavez’s decision to place the country on its own time zone, which makes it a half-hour out of synch with the rest of the continent.
  • A judge in Argentina has invoked the principle of universal jurisdiction to order the arrest of 20 former Spanish officials accused of torturing dissidents under Spain’s Franco dictatorship, as the New York Times reports.
  • Argentine President Cristina Fernandez’s health is in the news yet again today, as yesterday her administration announced that she had been hospitalized for an “infectious fever,” according to La Nacion. The AP notes that this is at least the fourth health problem that the president has suffered in the past year.
  • Over the weekend the Associated Press ran a profile of El Salvador’s Israel Ticas, one of the few forensic scientists in the country. Though he works for the Attorney General as its only criminologist, Ticas’ forensic expertise is actually self-taught.  
  • More than a week after Uruguay’s general election, electoral officials have released the final results. The vote count confirms that the ballot lists of the ruling Frente Amplio (FA) coalition were supported by 47.8 percent by voters, four points more than those received by the opposition National and Colorado Parties combined (30.88 percent and 12.89 percent, repectively). As El Pais reports, this ensures that the FA will control the lower house with 50 seats, and will hold 15 seats in the Senate. If FA candidate Tabare Vazquez wins the runoff -- as he seems poised to -- his vice president Raul Sendic will win a Senate seat, continuing the coalition’s majority control over both legislative houses.
  • Spanish news agency EFE has an update on the peace process in Havana and the arrival of the latest delegation of conflict victims to the talks. According to UN facilitators of the victims’ participation, there have been at least three cases of armed groups issuing death threats to victims who have testified in Havana since the current stage of talks began.