Monday, August 20, 2012

Why Did Correa Grant Asylum to Julian Assange?

In the wake of Ecuador’s decision to grant asylum to WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, many commentators agree that the move has more to do with President Rafael Correa’s anti-US stance than with the merits of the case itself.

An op-ed in the NYT says that the decision is closely tied to Western Hemisphere politics, and has little to do with Ecuador’s relationship with the UK. For Haverford College’s Anita Isaacs, the decision is “an attempt by Mr. Correa to settle old scores with the United States, display his political prowess in the run-up to Ecuadorean presidential elections next year and make a power play for a leadership role on the Latin American left.”

Isaacs relates the move back to Ecuador’s anger after WikiLeaks released cables in April 2011 in which the then-US ambassador accused Correa of having appointed a corrupt police chief on purpose. She also points out that Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez’s illness has created an opening for a leftist president to take on a regional leadership role, which Correa is making a play for.

The Wall Street Journal concurs, arguing in dramatic language that Correa is “doing his best to join the axis of world rogues,” and that his motivation is to join forces with a “fellow enemy of Western democracies.”

A piece published on Upside Down World takes a similar view, but from the opposite side of the political spectrum, arguing that Correa’s decision is a “stand against neo-colonialist politics,” and speaking approvingly of the president’s repeated confrontation with US interests in the hemisphere. The article quotes Mark Weisbrot of the Center for Economic and Policy Research as saying that the criticisms of Correa as cracking down on press freedom are a gross exaggeration, and argues that “Most of the foreign press has chosen to ignore the principled positions of Correa, diverting attention to issues like press freedom.”

As noted in Friday’s post, the Global Post has argued that the decision may have more to do with Correa’s wish to present himself as a protector of press freedom than with anti-US feeling.

Assange made a speech from the balcony of Ecuador’s Embassy in London on Sunday, accusing the US of carrying out a “witch hunt” against him, and claiming that there was an FBI investigation in progress, reports the NYT.

Meanwhile regional body UNASUR issued a statement criticizing the UK’s threat to enter the embassy and arrest Assange, but did not give its endorsement to Correa’s position, as the AP reports.

News Briefs

  • The Miami Herald’s Andres Oppenheimer reports that Uruguay’s proposal for the state to sell marijuana “may not be that crazy.” President Jose Mujica revealed in an interview that the government will subcontract a private firm to manage the business, which for Oppenheimer removes the risk that the move would create a “inept, state-run bureaucracy filled with government cronies” that could be corrupted by the drug trade. Mujica told him that the bill has a 50-50 chance of passing, but that he hopes it or a similar proposal will be adopted soon.
  • Former Colombian President Alvaro Uribe claimed that the government of Juan Manuel Santos is negotiating with the FARC rebel group in Cuba, calling it “incomprehensible,” reports Colombia Reports. The Santos administration has denied holding talks with the guerrillas, though it has made moves towards creating the legal framework for such a process. La Silla Vacia has a piece saying that Santos is increasingly adopting Uribe’s style in his dealings with the public, sending out Tweets in first-person style, giving interviews to community radio stations, and being photographed riding a horse -- though, as the site points out, the downside was that the horse was being led with a halter harness.
  • Belize has threatened not to pay its debts unless 45 percent is written off their value or it is given a 15 year freeze on paying, reports the WSJ. The country announced its intentions in a note posted on the website of its central bank on August 8, shocking analysts and investors, according to the newspaper. The WSJ argues that Belize may have been encouraged by the “Greek effect” to take a tough line with creditors.
  • The Washington Post reports on the falling murder rate in Mexico’s Ciudad Juarez, noting that the new calm in the one-time world murder capital may be due not to the government’s security efforts but to Sinaloa Cartel kingpin “El Chapo” consolidating his control over the city. InSight Crime makes the same argument in a piece which says that while Chapo’s victory is the most disheartening explanation for the decline in killings, it is also the most plausible.
  • Mexico has replaced all 348 federal police assigned to guard Mexico City airport, bringing in officers who have been carefully vetted, following a deadly shootout between police in June, reports the AP. Two officers involved in the case are still on the run, and released a statement claiming that the dead men had been trying to force them to join a drug trafficking ring.
  • The governor of a Venezuelan state said that Cuba’s inefficient management of a key port has contributed to food shortages, reports the Miami Herald. Carabobo Governor Henrique Salas Feo said that since Puerto Cabello port was put under the management of a Venezuelan-Cuban company in 2009, the delay in imports entering the country has gone from 72 hours to 30 days.
  • Also from the Miami Herald, a report that the Spanish politician who was driving during the car when dissident Oswaldo Paya was killed will go to trial in Cuba on August 31.
  • The Central American Court of Justice (CACJ) has ruled against the Salvadoran Constitutional Chamber in its clash with the government, declaring that the body’s decision that the government’s selection of Supreme Court magistrates was illegal was itself illegal. As Tim’s El Salvador Blog reports, the ruling was rejected by the chamber, and did not seem to have an effect on the positions of the parties negotiating over the constitutional crisis.
  • In Puerto Rico, voters rejected a constitutional amendment that would have ended automatic entitlement to bail and reduced the size of the legislature, reports the AP.
  • Simon Romero at the NYT reports on a boom in psychoanalysis in Argentina, where the number of practising psychologists went from 145 per 100,000 in 2008 to 196 last year, dwarfing the figure of 27 per 100,000 in the US.

Friday, August 17, 2012

Examining Ecuador's Decision to Grant Assange Asylum

Ecuador announced Thursday that it would grant the asylum request of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange.

But Britain's Foreign Secretary William Hague reaffirmed that the UK could not give Assange safe passage to leave the country. He also denied that the UK would consider removing the Ecuadorian embassy’s diplomatic status, which would allow British law enforcement to enter the building and arrest Assange. As the AFP points out, “Entering the embassy without Ecuador's permission would challenge a fundamental principle of diplomacy, and the threat has left Britain in unchartered legal waters.”

Britain would be able to revoke the embassy building’s diplomatic status based on a little-known piece of legislation passed in 1987. The Diplomatic and Consular Premises Act was passed after a gunman killed a police officer by firing from inside the Libyan embassy in London in 1984. The gunman avoided arrest by staying inside the building, and was eventually able to leave the country.

As the Telegraph explains, it’s unclear whether this Act would apply in Assange’s case, which does not involve a breach of international law like terrorism. Removing the Ecuadorian embassy’s diplomatic status could also feed a diplomatic crisis for Britian across the world, if other countries retaliate by removing the status of Britian’s embassies.

In a press conference  in Quito, Ecuadorian Foreign Minister Ricardo Patiño said that he did not think Britain would resort to such measures, Reuters reports. "I don't think they will dare to infringe international law,” Patiño said.

If Britain refuses to grant refugee status to WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, allowing him safe passage out of England to Ecuador, the case will be brought towards the International Court of Justice, Assange’s lawyer said, as the Telegraph reports. Britain's foreign secretary added that the legal stalemate could continue for months, or even longer.

The Telegraph does lay out one scenario in which Assange could possibly leave the country without being arrested:

“Diplomatic immunity applies to an embassy's means of transportation as well as its building, meaning Assange could be transported to the airport safely by an official Ecuadoran car. But British police could intervene legally if he steps foot on the pavement to get from the Embassy to the car, or walks from the car through the airport to a plane. There have even been suggestions that Assange could be transported over these short distances using a diplomatic bag, which are also safe from interference by a home nation.”

The Guardian also examines a set of possible exit strategies.

Ecuador’s decision to grant Assange his asylum request was largely interpreted as evidence of Ecuador’s ability to take such an action, without fear of serious political repercussions from either the US or the UK. According to the AP’s analysis:

"Offering asylum to the man responsible for the biggest-ever spilling of U.S. secrets was apparently too attractive for Correa to resist. It let him stake a claim to moral high ground, associating himself with a man whose loyalists consider him a digital age Robin Hood crusading against abuses of big governments and corporations."

But Ecuador likely arrived at its decision for other reasons that have little to do with “poking the US in the eye,” to paraphrase a comment that U.S. Representative Eliot Engel (D-NY) made to the AP. Global Post points out that by granting Assange asylum, President Rafael Correa “could be looking  to re-position himself as a defender of journalistic freedom.” It is also worth noting that presenting the US as an actor with interests in the Assange case raises tricky questions, as the US State Department has publicly asserted that it has no interest in getting involved or in persecuting Assange (Assange and his supporters contend otherwise).

Global Post also examines the Ecuadorian foreign ministry’s official statement granting asylum to Assange, and argues that it possible to “detect a whiff of hypocrisy” in the document’s justification of Assange’s asylum. According to the Global Post, the statement cites several conventions which are “keystones” for the Inter-American Human Rights Comission, which Correa has previously criticized for its alleged double standards.

At the Guardian, Mark Weisbrot of the Centre for Economic and Policy Research makes his own case for why Ecuador offered Assange asylum and was justified in doing so, asserting that “Correa made this decision because it was the only ethical thing to do.” The BBC has its own take on Ecuador’s decision, noting that if nothing else, Correa’s choise is “unsurprising.”

In other coverage, Bloggings by Boz looks ahead for what Assange’s asylum case could mean for similar cases playing out across Latin America, particularly if other regional bodies including the OAS, ALBA, and UNASUR choose to weigh in. More from the London Review of Books, the Wall Street Journal (with a timeline), and the AP.

News Briefs
  • Dominican Republic President Danilo Medina was sworn into office, reports the BBC. Medina comes to power after a controversial election in May in which his opponent, former President Hipolito Mejia, rejected the results.
  • The Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR) released its findings on what happened on May 11 in Honduras, when four boat passengers were shot dead during an anti-drug operation that involved Honduran and Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) agents. The report, based on a visit made in July, focuses on collecting information from surviving victims and other eyewitnesses, and reconstructs a narrative of the day’s events. The report concludes that the “military-style tactics applied to drug interdiction efforts” in Honduras are negatively impacting local indigenous communities, and “are not yielding effective results.” The Honduran investigation of the incident is moving slowly and is of “poor quality,” the CEPR notes, arguing that US has not been sufficiently cooperative. Honduras Culture and Politics notes that Honduran media have focused on the CEPR’s finding that the DEA played a more significant role in the operation than was originally claimed. 
  • The  trial of former Guatemala police chief Pedro García Arredondo began in Guatemala; Arredondo is accused of masterminding in the disappearance of a university student in 1981. More from Central American Politics. 
  • The Economist praises President Dilma Rousseff’s decision to partly privatize Brazil’s infrastructure: “Ms Rousseff, like her party, is instinctively hostile to anything akin to privatisation. But she has clearly concluded that without private-sector involvement, the infrastructure Brazil needs will never be built.”
  • Although Mexico claims it has arrested seven suspects who have confessed to the murder of four media workers in Veracruz, the assertion has been met with skepticism. Mike O’Connor of the Committee to Protect Journalists to the New York Times: “Federal authorities say the confessions are worthless, lacking any prosecutable details. There is no crime scene, there is a place where they were found, but no place where they were killed, no weapons, no motive.”
  • The Economist argues that the five-month transition period until president-elect Enrique Peña Nieto takes power in Mexico may have given “undeserved coverage to Andrés Manuel López Obrador” due to a “news vacuum.” 

Thursday, August 16, 2012

Court Orders Halt to Brazil Mega-Dam

A Brazilian court has ordered work to be halted on the Belo Monte dam project in the Amazon region on the grounds that local indigenous groups have not been properly consulted.

The judges ruled that Congress could not legitimately authorize the project without full consultations and an independent assessment of its environmental impact. Upside Down World reports that the court found Congress’ approval of the dam in 2005 to be illegal under the terms of the constitution and International Labour Organization convention 169, which require indigenous groups to be consulted. The legislature approved the plan without an environmental impact study, and a subsequent impact study was approved by the federal environment agency under intense political pressure and against the objections of its employees, according to the website.


Local tribes fiercely oppose the hydroelectric dam, set to be the third-biggest in the world, because it will flood a 500 square kilometers of forest and divert 80 percent of water in the Xingu River, which they use for water supply, transport, and  fishing.

As the BBC reports, the lead judge on the case told Brazilian press "A study on the environmental impact of the project was required before, not after, work on the dam started. The legislation is flawed." Judge Antonio de Souza Prudente stated that “Indigenous people must be listened to and respected."

Consortium Norte Energia will face a fine of $250,000 a day if it continues work despite the court order, but it will be able to appeal against the decision.

The dam is expected to become fully operational in seven years time, and will supply some 26 million people with electricity. President Dilma Rousseff has promoted the project as a way to create jobs and help make Brazil more prosperous.

There have been protests against the project for years, including an occupation of the construction site by by hundreds of indigenous people during the G-20 summit in June. Last month, tribal leaders held three Norte Energia workers hostage for a few days to express their unhappiness with measures intended to mitigate the project’s impact.

Inter-Press Service commented that, although the ruling may just be another stage in a "long, drawn-out war" over the project, it does show that the courts are prepared to defend the rights of indigenous groups to have a say in how the land they live on is used.

In other news from Brazil, the government has announced plans to invest $66 billion in transport infrastructure, half of it in the next five years, reports the Associated Press.


News Briefs

  • On Wednesday night Ecuador’s government said that WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange could remain in its London Embassy indefinitely on humanitarian grounds, and that it would announce a decision on his asylum request Thursday, reports the NYT. Foreign Minister Ricardo Patiño claimed that the UK authorities had threatened to storm the embassy and arrest Assange, which he said would bring consequences. “We are not a British colony” explained the minister.
  • A group of alleged criminals, thought to belong to the Jalisco Cartel - New Generation have admitted to the murder of five journalists murdered in Veracruz, east Mexico, earlier this year, reports La Cronica de Hoy. The AP notes that Mexican security forces have been criticized for closing cases once a confession has been extracted, rather than carrying out a full investigation. Meanwhile in Monterrey, near the US border, nine people were killed when gunmen attacked a bar called the Matehuala Men’s Club, reported the AP.
  • Two US congressmen said they had evidence implicating Wal-Mart’s Mexican branch in money laundering and tax evasion, reports the WSJ. In April, the NYT broke the story that Wal-Mart de Mexico had paid bribes to officials to allow it to expand its network of stores across the country.
  • Mexican national Sandra Avila Beltran, known as the “Queen of the Pacific,” has been denied bail in Miami after being extradited to the US last week to stand trial on charges of drug trafficking. The Miami Herald reports that “the once-fashionable Avila was dressed in a drab khaki prison suit and orange rubber clogs, with shackles on her wrists and ankles.”
  • The US Treasury Department has announced sanctions against a daughter and a friend of a Guatemalan alleged trafficker known as the “Queen of the South,” Marllory Dadiana Chacon Rossell, as elPeriodico reports. Chacon is accused of laundering tens of millions of dollars in drug profits each month, according to the WSJ blog.
  • US Embassy officials have met with a US citizen being held in Venezuela on suspicion of being a mercenary, sent to stir up trouble in the country if the opposition lost the elections, reports the AP. 
  • Two Brazilian men were reportedly burnt alive by a mob in a Bolivian border town, where they had been arrested on suspicion of murder, according to the AP.
  • Student protests broke out again in Santiago on Tuesday, with young people demanding radical reform to make the education system more affordable, following the burning of city buses during protests last week. City Mayor Pablo Zalaquett has threatened to remove scholarships from students who occupy school buildings, reports the AP.
  • The NYT reports from the tent camps of Haiti, which were set up to house those left homeless after the January 2010 earthquake but have become a permanent home for hundreds of thousands of people. “In the absence of an overarching housing policy, Haiti’s shelter problem has been tackled unsystematically, in a way that has favored rural over urban victims and homeowners over renters because their needs were more easily met.”
  • The Toronto Star has a feature on the ongoing hunger strike by a group of Colombian former employees of General Motors, who have sewn their lips shut to protest against the company, which they say fired them without compensation after they received injuries on the job. Four sewed their mouths shut on August 1, and another three a week later, and they say more will join each week if their demand for compensation is not met.
  • The WSJ reports on the tourism renaissance in the wine-producing Valle de Guadalupe in Baja California, northwest Mexico.

Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Mixed Messages From Ecuador on Assange’s Asylum Request

Citing unnamed officials familiar with the matter, the Guardian reported yesterday that the government of Ecuador has decided that it will grant WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange’s request for asylum. Nevertheless, Ecuadoran President Rafael Correa dismissed this report Tuesday afternoon via Twitter, saying that a final decision had not yet been made.

In a television interview with Ecuadoran public television on Monday, President Rafael Correa said that a verdict on Assange’s asylum bid could be expected this week, and that it would come after a meeting with Foreign Minister Ricardo Patiño, which is scheduled for today.

This is not the first time that authorities have promised to issue a final pronouncement on the matter, however. On June 20, the day after the WikiLeaks founder fled to Ecuador’s London embassy, Deputy Foreign Minister Marco Albuja assured reporters that the government would reach a decision in 24 hours. Still, this latest announcement appears to be more reliable. President Correa repeated his promise on Tuesday to BBC Mundo, and Patiño also tweeted a confirmation of today’s scheduled meeting late last night.

Much of the reporting on Assange’s petition has centered on the irony of his appeal to Ecuador. The Correa administration has earned a reputation as hostile to independent media in the country, which clashes significantly with Assange’s image as a free speech and transparency advocate.

But the main obstacle to the WikiLeaks director’s request for political asylum in Ecuador is the difficulty he would face in leaving the country, as UK police have authority to arrest him the instant he leaves embassy property. As Patiño told Reuters recently: "It's not only about whether to grant the asylum, because for Mr. Assange to leave England he should have a safe pass from the British (government). Will that be possible? That's an issue we have to take into account."

Leaving the UK may not be entirely out of the question, however. International law experts have offered a variety of ways in which the Ecuadoran government could legally slip the WikiLeaks head out of Great Britain, including classifying him as “diplomatic baggage” or naming him a United Nations ambassador.

Ultimately, fleeing the country may not even be necessary for Assange. If he is granted asylum he could potentially remain in Ecuador’s embassy indefinitely. While this would be an unusual measure, it is not without precedent. Hungarian Cardinal Jozsef Mindszenty, an outspoken critic of the then pro-Soviet government of Hungary, lived in the American Embassy in Budapest for 15 years, from 1956 to 1971.


News Briefs

  • Over the weekend The Daily Beast reported that Mitt Romney’s chosen running mate Paul Ryan has received several foreign policy briefings from former Assistant Secretary of State Elliot Abrams. Abrams is best known for pleading guilty to covering up the Iran-Contra scandal in 1991 and working to deny the most publicized atrocity committed by the government during El Salvador’s civil war, the 1981 El Mozote massacre. Greg Weeks points out that Romney himself has several right-wing Latin America policy advisors (like the Heritage Foundation’s Ray Walser), and suggests that a Romney victory in November could cause foreign policy towards the region to be dominated by “Cold Warriors” openly hostile to leftist governments.
  • Cuban Triangle notes that Ryan’s views on Cuba were not always in line Romney’s current support of the embargo. In 2002, Congressman Ryan argued in favor of unrestricted travel to the island, saying “travel is a device that opens closed societies.” Univision reports that Romney visited Miami on Monday in order to assure the Cuban-American community there that his vice president pick had “changed his position after meeting with South Florida Cuban lawmakers Ileana Ros-Lehtinen and Mario and Lincoln Diaz-Balart.”
  • Fidel Castro turned 86 on Monday, and while state media published commemorative essays in his honor, the Cuban leader made no public appearances. The AP suggests that this is yet another sign of Castro’s diminished role in the country.
  • In a continuation of his attacks on the Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) for allegedly buying votes in July’s elections, leftist presidential candidate Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador appeared at a press conference in Mexico City on Tuesday with a pig, a sheep and several chickens. Lopez Obrador claimed to have evidence that the PRI promised the farm animals to rural Mexicans in exchange for their votes. The AP gleefully reports that “the pig was the most vocal of the group.”
  • The LA Times’ World Now blog with a look at the politicized nature of homicide statistics in Mexico. While the administration of President Felipe Calderon claims that homicides linked to organized crime fell 15 percent in the first half of 2012 compared to the same period last year, independent analysts say the figure has actually risen by 10 percent.
  • During a conference at a university in Medellin on Tuesday, Colombian ex-president Alvaro Uribe claimed that, while in office, he considered ordering a military operation in Venezuelan territory aimed at FARC and ELN guerrillas. According to Uribe, he opted to denounce guerrilla presence in the neighboring country through the Organization of American States instead because he “didn’t have time” to organize a military campaign. Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez shot back soon after that rather than lacking time, Uribe simply “didn’t have the ‘cojones’” to launch an attack on Venezuelan soil.
  • Colombian state prosecutors on Tuesday ordered the release of politician Sigifredo Lopez, who had been jailed since May on suspicion of helping the FARC kidnap 11 other local legislators in 2002.
  • The trial against former Argentine president Fernando de la Rua, accused of paying $5 million to four senators in exchange for voting for the elimination of worker protection regulations in 2000, began on Tuesday in Buenos Aires. Clarin reports that former intelligence chief Fernando de Santibanes and former Labor Minister Alberto Flamarique are also suspected of involvement in the scandal.
  • Newly-installed Paraguayan President Federico Franco has indicated that he is considering backing out of a power-sharing agreement with Brazil over the Itaipu Dam, the world’s biggest hydroelectric facility. The dam has been jointly operated by Brazil and Paraguay since its completion in 1984, but tensions between the two countries have risen ever since Brazil endorsed Paraguay’s suspension from the Mercosur trading bloc in response to the recent ouster of former president Fernando Lugo.

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

In Cabral Murder Case, Plenty of Loose Ends

Nicaragua investigative journalism website Confidencial reports that as the trial against nightclub owner Henry Fariñas continues, the Attorney General’s Office faces the challenge of proving in court that Fariñas did in fact form part of a money laundering and organized crime network.

The trial, set to start on August 22, involves Fariñas and 34 other people accused of being involved in a drug trafficking ring.

Fariñas was transporting Argentine singer Facundo Cabral to the airport in Guatemala in July 2011, when their vehicle was attacked by gunmen. Fariñas was critically injured in the attack and Cabral was killed, setting off an international investigation that has connected criminal activites from Mexico to Guatemala to Colombia. After Fariñas returned to Nicaragua, he was arrested in April 2012 and charged with drug trafficking and money laundering.

As Confidencial reports, if prosecutors are to successfully carry out their case against Fariñas, they will have to use solid evidence in court. One 97-page police report, obtained by Confidencial,  describes 15 front companies that were allegedly used by Fariñas’ network to launder cash. However, he is only named as an official business partner in two of the companies: a music business and a nightclub.

Confidencial notes that while the 15 companies are listed as having handled some $6.4 million dollars and about 658 million cordobas between 2005 and 2012, much of that money cannot be accounted for. At the moment, none of the companies have any funds in their bank accounts, raising the question of where all the cash went.

One of Fariñas’ business dealings is reportedly behind the Cabral murder. Fariñas owned the Elite nightclub, which alleged Costa Rican drug trafficker Alejandro Jimenez, alias “El Palidejo,” wanted to buy. When Fariñas refused, Jimenez ordered the assasination attempt that accidentally killed Cabral, the theory goes.

In her first public interview, Fariñas’ wife told Confidencial that her husband was only the “manager” of Elite, not the owner, and that he obtained the position by “interviewing” for it. Jimenez was just a client at Elite, she added.

As the Confidencial report points out, there are plenty of loose ends about the case that prosecutors will have to wrap up when the trial begins. in a case that will likely be seen as a serious test for Nicaragua’s judicial insitutions.

The report includes a helpful 17-minute video giving background to the Fariñas-Cabral affair, as well as selections from Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) reports sent to Nicaraguan police about Fariñas’ alleged illicit activities.


News Briefs
  • The AP with a clarification on its report yesterday that the US is cutting security aid to Honduras. The US Ambassador to Honduras told the news agency that while overall aid is not being cut to Honduras, no US funds will be handled by controversial police chief Juan Carlos Bonilla, accused of once running a death squad. A US State Department report sent to Congress last Wednesday actually states that Honduras has met all its human rights requirements. But a portion of the $56 million in funds approved by Congress cannot go to Bonilla or his subordinates until he is properly vetted. 
  • Colombia’s Defense Minister has said the government will continue to revise its military strategy in the embattled Cauca department, where guerrilla group the FARC maintains its tough offensive, reports El Espectador. Adding to tensions in the department was the death of a Nasa indigenous leader by unidentified gunmen, reports the BBC.
  • An Op-Ed in the New York Times argues that Rio de Janeiro is carrying out illegal evictions in the name of prepping the country for the 2016 Olympics. Plans to redevelop the city’s port area puts its most historic favela, Providência (founded in 1897), at risk, the Op-Ed authors state. While the city has said that the redevelopment plans will ultimately benefit local residents, the city has pursued a “divide and conquer” approach, only negotiating with residents individually for their relocation rather than allowing entire communities to bargain as a group. “If Rio succeeds in disfiguring and dismantling its most historic favela, the path will be open to further destruction throughout the city’s hundreds of others,” the Op-Ed concludes.
  • Colombia newspaper El Tiempo on a new report, set to be released Wednesday by the Colombia Family Welfare Institute, that estimates some 18,000 minors currently form part of guerrilla groups or armed gangs. AlertNet has a profile of former child combatants that depicts some of the challenges of reintegration into civilian life. 
  • Ecuador will decide this week whether to provide asylum to Wikileaks founder Julian Assange, President Rafael Correa said Monday. From Reuters.
  • The LA Times notes that even though Brazil is technically in the middle of an economic slowdown, “the unemployment rate is still at a record low, wages have risen, and more than 1 million jobs have been created this year.” But there is still a threat of an economic crisis that could impact the nation’s middle class far more than the wealthy.  Mark Weisbrot of the the Center for Economic and Policy Research in Washington: "If growth doesn't start again, this will hit people in their daily lives.”
  • Chilean President Sebastian Piñera said Monday that he rejects decriminalizing small amounts of marijuana possession and growth for personal use, in light of a bill presented last week by opposition party lawmakers that would decriminalize such activities. “At this time in which some propose or promote legalizing drugs, I want to say the government of Chile is firmly committed to combating drug use,” said Piñera, after signing an anti-drug and alcohol education bill into law. Still, as InSight Crime points out, that opposition lawmakers attempted to push through a decriminalization bill at all is another indication of the increased resistance across the region to the traditional hardline drug laws. Uruguay is still leading the way with its proposal to legalize the marijuana trade. The bill was sent to Congress on August 8 and can be read in full, in English, at the Beckley Foundation. 
  • Mary Anastasia O’Grady at the Wall Street Journal argues that her July 30 column made waves in El Salvador, even prompting President Mauricio Funes to send his foreign minister to Washington D.C. in July, to “advance [Funes’] version of events.” In her previous column, O’Grady called for the Obama administration to cut off Millenium Challenge Corporation (MCC) aid to El Salvador, if the Funes government did not comply with the constitutional court’s ruling on appointments to the Supreme Court. By not accepting the ruling, it would be possible to cut off MCC grants to El Salvador, which require that a government “respect the constitution,” O’Grady argues. 
  • Time magazine with a general overview of El Salvador’s gang truce, noting that “even the nation’s financial market has received the ‘peace accord’ with open arms.” The government, meanwhile, is still careful to distance itself from the truce, even as figures like Public Security Minister David Payes are sounding a more conciliatory note than their past anti-gang rhetoric. Payes, a retired general who once said that his security strategy would involve locking up an additional 10,000 gang members, told Time that the government was focused on gang prevention and job creation schemes in neighborhoods afflicted by violence. “We also think that former gang members could form part of this effort, so that they not only benefit but that they help us administer and develop antigang programs,” Payes told the magazine. 
  • Non-profit the Venezuelan Prisons Observatory reports that prison violence rose 15 percent compared to the same period last year, reports the AP. So far in 2011, “riots and clashes” between inmates has resulted in 304 deaths.
  • 13 years after the assassination of Colombian political satirist Jaime Garzon, the Attorney General’s office will charge paramilitary leader Diego Murillo, alias “Don Berna,” as one of the conspirators behind the crime, reports Verdad Abierta. 
  • The LA Times with an on-the-ground feature on a street protest led by student youth movement “I am 132” in Mexico City. The article describes the student movement as “at its moment of peak momentum and hype,” but notes that it is still struggling somewhat to find its voice. The movement “may end up being swallowed by the clamor of protest that is part of the country's daily dose of ambient noise,” the article states. “But like other outsiders who have stirred the Mexican moral imagination, it may also become something more.” 
  • The Guardian’s Poverty Matters blog examines the midpoint of President Juan Manuel Santos’ administration, describing the president’s policies as “modern and decent.” “Santos is a liberal, not a neoliberal,” the article states, citing some of the president’s policies aimed at combating inequality, modeled partly on Brazil’s experience. 


Monday, August 13, 2012

U.S. Restricts Security Aid to Honduras

In a surprise move, the U.S. Department of State has announced that it will suspend aid to Honduran police units under the direct command of the country’s new national police chief while diplomatic officials look into claims that he ran a death squad in the early 2000s.

Citing a State Department report that doesn’t seem to have been made public, the Associated Press reports that the U.S. is aware of allegations against National Police Chief Juan Carlos Bonilla, and has established a working group to investigate them.  The U.S. is also restricting its aid to police in the country, and until further notice will only provide funds to Honduran personnel “who receive training, guidance, and advice directly from U.S. law enforcement and are not under Bonilla’s direct supervision.”

The memo reportedly takes care to point out that, despite these allegations, Honduras meets the human rights requirements necessary in order to receive security aid. Thus, the State Department is not obligated to withhold a percentage of overall aid to the country, as was the case with Mexico in September 2010, when 15 percent of security aid was held back due to human rights concerns.

The AP notes that the decision was made in response to “a series of letters from Honduran and U.S. academics, activists and members of Congress [which] were sent to U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton asking her to reconsider security aid to Honduras because of alleged human rights violations.” The article quotes a June 7 letter which stated, in part, that “Combatting drug trafficking is not a legitimate justification for the U.S. to fund and train security forces that usurp democratic governments and violently repress our people.”

But while the newly announced restrictions on aid will likely be hailed as a victory for Honduran human rights advocates, Mike Allison of Central American Politics points out that the move stops far short of most actual demands in the letter, which include cutting off all security aid and a local referendum on U.S. military bases in the country.  

Honduras Culture and Politics presents another drawback to the announcement: the fact that the new funding guidelines will likely not apply to a controversial proposed law enforcement unit.  Known as the “Tigres,” the elite unit will fall under the jurisdiction of both the Defense Department and Security Ministry, blurring the line between domestic policing and military operations.

News Briefs

  • The Houston Chronicle with the latest round of fear mongering over Venezuela-Iran links. The paper claims that American officials are concerned about a far-fetched and improbable scenario: that “Iranian-backed terrorists could reach to the rim of Latin America, pick up fake Venezuelan passports and sneak into the United States” via the Mexico border.
  • As noted in Friday’s Post, the Venezuelan government has detained an American citizen accused of being a “mercenary” hired to destabilize the government. President Hugo Chavez has since told reporters that the suspect was a former U.S. Marine, but little else has been revealed about the man or the evidence against him.
  • Milenio reports that the PRI mayor-elect of the town of Matehuala, in the central state of San Luis Potosi, was killed along with his advisor on Sunday morning by unknown gunmen. While San Luis Potosi has largely been spared the kind of bloodshed seen in northern border states, InSight Crime has suggested that a recent spike in violence there could be the result of a turf war between the Zetas and local allies of the Sinaloa Cartel.
  • Mexico’s Supreme Court has ruled that a military colonel accused of covering up evidence of torture should be tried by a civilian court.
  • The United Nations’ Special Rapporteur of Indigenous Rights has called on Colombia to respect the rights of indigenous people in the southern Cauca department, where the local Nasa tribe has requested that federal forces and guerrillas alike withdraw from their land. McClatchy has an interesting profile of the local “indigenous guard,” an unarmed volunteer force tasked with keeping the peace in Nasa territory.
  • The Miami Herald looks at Wikileaks founder Julian Assange’s request for asylum in Ecuador, and the surprising ideological overlap between the free speech advocate and President Rafael Correa, who has cracked down on independent media in his country.
  • Despite the recent slowdown in Brazil’s economy, an LA Times investigation suggests that average Brazilians have not been impacted. Economist Tony Volpon told the paper that economists are stumped by “how you can have an economy that was growing at 7.5% just over a year ago and is now at zero, but with unemployment still dropping.”
  • Organizers in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, watched the closing ceremony of the London Olympics on Sunday with apprehension, reports the AP, kicking off “four years of pre-games jitters and a race against the clock to ready this notoriously laid-back beach city for the global sports showcase.”
  • The New York Times profiles the city of Buenos Aires’ recent decision to give pensions of up to $900 a month to retired writers. Beyond the fact that this is an attempt  at honoring the country’s proud literary tradition, the policy is a prime example of Argentina’s unique economic policies, marked by generous social investment at a time when governments around the world are embracing austerity.

Friday, August 10, 2012

Bogota Mayor Proposes Drug Centers for Addicts

Bogota Mayor Gustavo Petro has stirred controversy by proposing the establishment of centers in the city that would allow addicts safe access to drugs, in order to cut drug-related crime.

The centers would be established in three areas of Colombia’s capital where there is a high concentration of people hooked on a crack-like cocaine derivative called “bazuko,” as the AFP reports. Petro, a former guerrilla with the M-19 rebel organization, said that the plan would need the approval of the national government. He announced that for now he will focus on the first stage of the scheme, sending vans around the city staffed with doctors and psychologists to give healthcare to drug users and gather information about the dimensions of the problem, as Semana reports.

The mayor’s plans have met with strong opposition from some sectors in the country. Inspector General Alejandro Ordoñez, a deeply conservative Catholic, said that Petro “must be smoking pot,” an accusation he later retracted, according to Colombia Reports. Health Minister Beatriz Londoño said that the government could not take the role of supplying drugs to users, reports Semana.

Semana published a list of Ordoñez’s objections to the proposal. He argued that the scheme was unconstitutional, that it was a criminal and not a public health policy, and that it would give rise to a contradiction with the state’s policy of combating drug trafficking.

El Espectador argues that the proposal is a good idea, and that if Colombia is to start treating drugs as a public health problem, Bogota should lead the way by helping to bring addicts from the margins of society. It says however that the moralist opponents of the measure have some justification, in that Petro gave little detail of his proposal, leading some to think that the drug distribution centers would encourage drug use amongst young people. The newspaper calls for Petro to carry out detailed studies and proposals to give weight to the plan.

One recent study showed that 15 percent of all homicides in Bogota are drug-related, as Terra reports.
In Colombia, the possession of small quantities of drugs for personal use has been decriminalized. The country also recently passed a law which dictates that drug use should be treated as a public health problem and not as a crime.

The director of addict care center Nuevos Rumbos told the AFP that, if the measure succeeds, it would be the first in the world to help crack addicts, as similar centers in Europe have focused on heroin addicts.

Meanwhile, in Uruguay, a bill that would allow the government to sell marijuana to licensed users has been put before Congress. One official told the Associated Press that the Mujica administration does not expect the bill to advance quickly. The government would control the import and sale of the drug, in a market that is thought to be worth $30-40 billion.

News Briefs

  • A US citizen has been arrested in Venezuela on suspicion of being a mercenary sent to destabilize the country if President Hugo Chavez wins the upcoming elections, reports the AP. The president said that the man, detained while crossing the border from Colombia, might have been recruited by the opposition to incite violent protests if they lose in October.
  • Fourteen bodies were found in a truck in the central Mexican state of San Luis Potosi, seemingly victims of drug violence kidnapped from nearby Coahuila state, reports the LA Times. The newspaper notes that San Luis Potosi has in the past seen less violence than many other parts of the country. Reuters says that this is the fifth time in recent months that 14 bodies have been found in Mexico, suggesting that the number may be some sort of code for drug traffickers.
  • Mexican alleged drug trafficker Sandra Avila Beltran, known as the “Queen of the Pacific” has been extradited to the US to face charges of smuggling drugs to Chicago. She was arrested in Mexico City in 2007, but her lawyers fought extradition, arguing that she had been cleared of similar charges in Mexico, reports the AP. The LA Times notes reports that she had a doctor visit her in prison to give her Botox injections, and says that she is accused of being “a rare figure -- a powerful woman -- in Latin America’s testosterone-saturated drug world,” her rise helped by relationships with high-level traffickers.
  • A Salvadoran drug trafficker known as “Chepe Luna,” who was captured by Honduran police on Tuesday, was freed the following day after the courts found there were no outstanding charges against him, as InSight Crime reports. Bloggings by Boz points out that there are more than 6,000 people in Honduran jails who have not been tried -- “The one time that the world would have benefited by having the Honduran court system move a bit more slowly, they are a model of efficiency and speed.” El Faro reports that Salvadoran President Mauricio Funes said his country’s intelligence services had assisted in the operation to arrest Chepe Luna.
  • Honduras Culture and Politics looks at the country’s plans for a SWAT-style elite police unit which will train on military bases, and in times of war will be under the command of the defense minister. The team would support President Lobo's “goal of merging the Security and Defense Ministries. It also continues a troubling trend of merging civilian policing and military defense,” argues the blog.
  • A Swedish politician who was in a car with Cuban dissident Oswaldo Paya at the time of his death in a crash said that he is worried about the Spanish citizen who was driving, who may face manslaughter charges, reports the AP. Aron Modig, who was allowed to return to Sweden, said that he had faced days of high-pressure questioning from officials in Cuba, who wanted to know what he was doing in the country, but did not ask anything about the crash or how it took place.
  • Colombia Reports reports that attacks on power stations allegedly carried out by the FARC guerrillas in southwest Colombia have left some 30,000 people in Cauca and Valle del Cauca without electricity.
  • A piece published in the Miami Herald looks at Brazil’s ethanol industry, which it says is helping the country move towards energy independence, with oil imports falling to almost zero.
  • The Washington Post reports on the struggle of a gay couple in Medellin, Colombia, to gain joint legal guardianship of their children. The pair married in Germany, and their partnership is recognized by Colombian law, but the woman who did not give birth to the children would have no legal right to see them if her partner were to die. The WP reports that legal challenges across the region have “led to a range of rulings that are giving gays once unthinkable rights in a traditionally conservative and Catholic region.”
  • The WSJ looks at the cycling boom in Latin America, with Buenos Aires building bike lanes and and Mexico City expanding a public bike program. Colombia and Chile are the leaders in bike lanes in the region, according to the report, which says “The change is remarkable for a region where drivers often imitate their Formula One heroes … and where enforcement of traffic laws is lax.”